Jules Richardson julesrichardsonuk at
Fri Dec 8 13:26:41 CST 2006

Marvin Johnston wrote:
 > Has anyone seen stiction on the IDE or later drives?

Yep, on early Connor IDE drives. I don't know if that happened to be a bad 
batch (I was testing them a couple of years after manufacture and 2/3 were DOA 
due to stiction), or "they were all like that, sir".

I don't recall seeing it on later IDE drives though, or on any SCSI drive 
(don't forget that some SCSI drives won't spin up without communication with 
the HBA, so can appear dead when power only is applied)

> Something else I've noticed is that if a drive has stiction, that stiction will
> return after the drive sets for a while again. Anyone know what actually causes
> stiction?

my *assumption* is that it's some sort of break-down in either the head 
material or the coating on the platters, such that when at rest of any period 
of time the heads manage to reattach themselves to the platters.

Unfortunately there seems to be no cure, expect for never powering the drive 
down until some other failure finally renders it useless.



there's a carp in the tub
there's a carp in the tub
so nobody's taken a bath

More information about the cctalk mailing list