PDP 11 gear finally moved
tothwolf at concentric.net
Wed Jul 22 10:17:43 CDT 2015
On Wed, 22 Jul 2015, tony duell wrote:
> I think he did answer it. If the unit is operating correctly then the
> capacitors must be sufficiently good at that time for that unit.
> Now, whether they will go on working is something that is very hard to
> tell. But that applies to every other component in the unit. An IC might
> work find now and suffer bond-out wire failure later on the same day.
Going purely from the historical data, failures of most semiconductors are
/far/ less frequent than an aluminum electrolytic capacitor (except for a
handful of certain TTL logic, which has been discussed previously here on
classiccmp and elsewhere).
>> Just like the NiCd and SLA batteries I mentioned, aluminum electrolytic
>> capacitors by their very electrochemical nature degrade as they age and
>> as they are used. You cannot claim that a 20-30 year aluminum
> Semiconductors also degrade both with time and use. I would think a
> 30-year-old 3 terminal regulator IC was also beyond its design life. So
> do you replace those 'anyway'? The damage done if one those fails is
> likely to greatly exceed the damage done if a capacitor fails.
Honestly, I've not seen all that many failed 3-terminal voltage regulators
in the field. I've seen some which failed due to insufficient cooling or a
loose heatsink, or with a hole blown in them after being hit with 24V AC,
but not any that have failed short under normal use.
> Do you replace all EPROMs in case they develop bit-rot (They are most
> likely way beyond their design life by now)?
I think like most of us on this list, anything I have which is mission
critical gets backed up and can easily be reprogrammed if it fails. Most
of the problems I've seen with bit-rot of EPROMs have been cases where
their quartz windows were not originally covered. I use opaque foil
stickers (I can see if I can find the part number for the stickers I use
if anyone needs it) on any UV erasable memories I program and I haven't
had issues with corrupt data.
More information about the cctalk